Skip to main content

Arts & Humanities Research (MPhil) (PhD)

Elizabeth Eleanor Jacqueline Atkinson

Animals and their Artists: An Exploration of Impossible Encounters

This research looks at the representation of animals in artistic practice to interrogate anthropocentric principles. I argue that the individuated and discrete human self – typically white, male, able-bodied and heterosexual – in possession of consciousness, rationality, empathy, a voice, and a face, is open to challenge by nonhuman capacities such as distributed cognition, gender ambiguity, metamorphosis, mimicry and avian speech. In traditional philosophy, animals represent all that is lacking in mankind. However, this dissertation argues that just because we frame ‘the animal’ as a negative term, our binary opposite and everything we are not, does not mean that animals have no meaning in themselves. Rather, animals in their very unknowability, mark the limits of human thinking. I analyse a selection of artistic representations of nonhuman animals which emphasise and experiment with these limits. The artists chosen all work with animals to create spaces where animal meaning takes centre stage and human meaning is side-lined. The marine life documented by Jean Painlevé and the praying mantis who disturbs Roger Caillois establish an erotic, subversive and Surrealist opening. I then shift to more recent exhibition of spiders (Tomás Saraceno) and silkworms (Candice Lin and Kumi Oda), bees and Glofish (Pierre Huyghe), parrots (Jennifer Allora and Guillermo Calzadilla) and ‘the animal within’ – brought to life as our primate kin (Huyghe). Each of these works places their human viewers in new territories and modes of relating to animal others, something increasingly vital in our current context: the rapid extinction of species, ecological collapse and the arrival of climate change at the hands of (some) Anthropos. If we look beyond human language, what wealth of material can be unearthed? By learning more about nonhuman ways of life, how are principles such as anthropocentrism, patriarchy and gender normativity destabilised? I identify examples of human traits amongst animals, positioning other species in unusual alliances with identities typically assumed to be human. But at the same time, I interrogate the superiority of these human traits in comparison to the wealth of abilities other animals have that humans do not, such as the sensuality of spiders, the tactility of octopuses, thmetamorphosis of silkworms or the collective organisation of bees. What happens to human subjectivity when faced with these radically other ways of being? When answering these questions, I elevate the status of animals from that of ‘the other’ to individuals mattering in their own right.  

To establish my argument, I align Derridean deconstruction with Critical Animal Studies theory, including that of Donna J. Haraway and Lynn Turner, as well as the unthought of N. Katherine Hayles and Xenofeminism’s embrace of alienation. I combine this discussion with the lesser known science theories of Jakob von Uexküll on animal Umwelten and Francisco Varela on embodied cognition. I apply a methodology inspired by the porosity and infinite connections of tentacular thinking and entanglement (Haraway) to encompass a range of approaches and positions. I weave animal bodies and knowledges into human bodies and constructions to establish lines of thought, forms and behaviours often overlooked. Through an encounter with these works and the species they exhibit, this thesis establishes a new position where differences are embraced. This is a space of exploration where what humans – with our limited perceptual worlds –
cannot and do not want to know materialises.   


Feature image: film still from Jean Painlevé and Geneviève Hamon, Les Amours de la pieuvre, 1967.

Degree Details

School of Arts & Humanities

Arts & Humanities Research (MPhil) (PhD)

Sponsors

TECHNE

Elizabeth Eleanor Jacqueline Atkinson is a writer, researcher and educator based in London. Her AHRC funded research project is entitled 'Animals and their Artists: An Exploration of Impossible Encounters'. This written dissertation will be published by Intellect in 2022. Elizabeth has had journal articles published with Antennae: Journal of Nature and Visual Culture, JAWS: Journal of Arts and Writing by Students, Something Other and Curating the Contemporary. In 2019 Elizabeth made a written contribution to the exhibition I Scared my Computer. Throughout her PhD Elizabeth has hosted and participated in international conferences and symposia including INTIMATERIAL, Silk Unravelled and Changing the Earth's (Sur)face: Adjusting Nature to Meet Human Needs. Prior to her PhD Elizabeth gained her Masters in the History of Art from the University of Glasgow, a BA in English Language and Literature from Kings College London and an Art and Design Foundation Diploma from Central Saint Martins.

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, After Alife Ahead, 2017.

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, After Alife Ahead, 2017. — A biotechnical system exhibited at Skulptur Projekte Münster 2017. Photo by author.

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, After Alife Ahead, 2017

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, After Alife Ahead, 2017 — A biotechnical system exhibited at Skulptur Projekte Münster 2017. Photo by author.

Exhibition view of: Tomás Saraceno, Webs of At-ten(sion), 2018.

Exhibition view of: Tomás Saraceno, Webs of At-ten(sion), 2018. — Included in On Air: Carte Blanche, Palais de Tokyo, Paris. Made up of 76 hybrid spider web sculptures interwoven by different spider species. Photography by Studio Tomás Saraceno, © Andrea Rossetti.

Still from: Pierre Huyghe, Untitled (Human Mask), 2014.

Still from: Pierre Huyghe, Untitled (Human Mask), 2014. — Film, colour, stereo, sound, 2:66. Running time: 19 minutes. Courtesy the artist; Marian Goodman Gallery, New York; Hauser & Wirth, London; Esther Schipper, Berlin and Anna Lena Films, Paris. © VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn, 2019. Film still © Pierre Huyghe

Still from: Jean Painlevé and Geneviève Hamon, Acèra ou Le Bal des sorcières, 1972

Still from: Jean Painlevé and Geneviève Hamon, Acèra ou Le Bal des sorcières, 1972 — Short film/documentary, running time 13 minutes.

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, Untilled (Liegender Frauenakt) [Reclining Nude], 2011-12, living sculpture.

Exhibition view of: Pierre Huyghe, Untilled (Liegender Frauenakt) [Reclining Nude], 2011-12, living sculpture. — Part of exhibition: Pierre Huyghe, Untilled, (2011-2). Alive entities and inanimate things, made and not made. Exhibition view: Untilled, dOCUMENTA 13, Kassel, 2012. Commissioned and produced by dOCUMENTA (13) with the support of Colección CIAC AC, Mexico; Foundation Louis Vuitton pour la création, Paris; Ishikawa Collection, Okayama, Japan. Courtesy the artist; Marian Goodman Gallery, New York; Esther Schipper, Berlin. © VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn, 2019. Photo © Pierre Huyghe.

Still from: Kumi Oda, Circle of Silk, 2016.

Still from: Kumi Oda, Circle of Silk, 2016. — Video, running time 9 minutes and 20 seconds. Courtesy the artist.

Still from: Allora and Calzadilla, The Great Silence, 2014.

Still from: Allora and Calzadilla, The Great Silence, 2014. — Three-channel video, running time 16 minutes and 52 seconds. In collaboration with Ted Chiang (subtitled text). Courtesy the artists.

Medium:

Photograph

TECHNE

AHRC Doctoral Training Partnership
Royal College of Art
Registered Office: Royal College of Art,
Kensington Gore, South Kensington,
London SW7 2EU
RCA™ Royal College of Art™ are trademarks
of the Royal College of Art